2 Aug - 57' Beneteau struck by lightning First symptom - starter contacts sticky (burned out the starter!) Second sympton - 24v battery charger not working Third - 24v Alternator fried Fourth - No GPS, Radar, depth, autopilot, wind indicator, rudder angle indicator, SSB, Sat phone, navtex, stereo, windlass remotes down Fifth - Generator won't start (CPU burned out) My bad, didn't realize it was lightning until I had already replaced the starter, battery charger AND the alternator. As all other equipment is 24v and run through the batteries and as the batteries had completely died as there was no way to charge them, it wasn't until I had fully charged the batteries and found none of the equipment working... First I thought it was just a faulty starter. As I'm just minding the boat, I didn't realize the batteries weren't getting charged via the shore power or alternator for a few days. As the battery charger was brand new and didn't have a mark on it, I had to send it out only to find out it wasn't working and they didn't know what was wrong with it. I had a mechanic come who discovered the fried 24v alternator. It was his opinion that the alternator had gone bad (bad diode?) allowing the battery charger to go... Luckily, now that we know it WAS lightning, we'll be covered by insurance. Whew! As the bill is going to be a big one for all that! Photos of the exploded VHF antenna and one of the fried Sea Talk boxes.
How did you get to looking for a bad starter if the batteries were dead? You should have gotten no starter click and the volt meter should have dropped. In addition I'd always try giving a suspect starter a wack while turning the key. No harm/no foul though since everything was fried and had to be replaced anyway.
No, went to bring boat in from mooring to the dock just a day or two after strike - batteries were still charged. By the time I got to the dock, the starter was burned out (about 15 minutes run time).
Hi, It sounds more like your starter failed to disengage and got burnt out by rotating for 15 mins, your batteries would have been supplying current all the time as well as the solenoid on a pre engaged starter won't release while the pinion is engaged with the flywheel. Did you see the starter opened up? Was all the solder thrown off the end of the commutator?
No, didn't see the starter opened up and am just going by what the electronics tech said (I trust him implicitly as he's an electrical engineer who used to contract for the defense industry). By the time Al came to diagnose why I didn't have any electronics after having new starter, charger, alternator in place, when I mentioned the faulty starter, he said he'd seen a few lightning strikes cause starter problems. By the time we found the burnt out Sea Talk unit, coupled with all the failures happening at the same time (everything had been running perfectly til then), and having gone up the mast to find a non-existent VHF antenna, what else but lightning could have caused all this? I'm open to suggestions! When I took the alternator in for repair, the first thing they asked was, "was the boat hit by lightning?" I'm also open to suggestions as to what else to look for as a result of a lightning strike. I've got a diver coming tomorrow to look at all the through hulls, running gear, zincs, etc.
There's not much I wouldn't be checking, including the terminus of all wires and grounds. Also check around the deck plates where the halyards are secured.
Kiwi, What about exit point? If VHF antenna was entry point and the Sea talk box was melted, would there necessarily be a noticeable exit? Dan
It had to exit somewhere, through hull fitting, ground plate, keel bolt, rudder post, prop shaft, look around and maybe have the boat hauled to be sure you are not missing something important.
run a dirty earth from the high point above last electronic fitting to a point of dispersal rudder bolt or something this will save any future burnouts and a crap load of money
Hi, The exit will be via the path of least resistance, as Castlerock says there are many points where the charge may have exited.
I was at the Stuart, FL Boat Show a few years ago and we had a thunderstorm. A bolt of lightning hit a radio tower next to the marina then hit a boat two boats over from the one I was on. I was leaning against the aluminum window frame, on the aft deck of a Hatteras MY when the bolt struck and I felt a shock in my arm. The next day I found out that all of my credit cards had been demagnetized by the lightning strike. I guess my wallet was the path of least resistance!
Hi, That's not a bad story to tell ya grandkids. Have you ever noticed how your cellphone can wipe out the info on those Hotel Room Keys that use the magnetic stripe to store data but the same phones don't seem to goose your credit cards when in your pocket with your wallet, even when ya have 2 of them in the same pocket!!
Hi K1W1, That's probably because the Hotel Room Keys have a 'lightweight' code recorded once onto the magnetic strip, which is designed to be erased so the card/key can be used again. The credit cards have the code permanently embeded into the strip not once, but dozens of times. This is to allow the stripe reader several chaces at picking up the code and also to ensure it can continue to be read if part of the strip is damaged or is worn down over time.