Trawlers Versus Cruisers?

Trawlers traditionally came in one flavor, single engine displacemetn hull. Today you have possible combinations of twin engines, diesel electric, semi displacement, mono or twin hull, etc etc. The single engine displacement boat is a very economical boat to operate, what it lacks in speed it gives you back in operating efficencies. However, the eternal question is always single or twin engine? No right or wrong answer, but always a debate. Having said all of this, as a rule, trawlers will be more fuel efficent with displacement hulls and PERHAPS more seaworthy than a similiarly sized planning hull. (I wouldn't bet the bank on that statement, though)

Remember, 80' is a large trawler, whereas plesure yachts can range from 150' to 200' easily. Big difference! To do your comparison fairly, compare a 65 to 80 foot trawler to 65 to 80 pleasure boat. Keep it all in perspective.

Is the popularity of trawlers similar of thr popularity of the SUV's on our roads?
The rugged, go anywhere, no sisy stuff image?

Generally speaking a full displacement hull will give a more seakindly ride than a semi-displacement or planning hull of the same length.
Trawlers have in the past been vessels built to full displacement designs (regardless of single or twin engine configuration) to operate at or below displacement speed (1.4 time the square root of the waterline length) yielding better economy in addition to a more comfortable ride.
More "seaworthy/safer" depends on the quality of construction and design.

Trawlers and expedition yachts seem to be gaining in popularity due to many owners wanting to extend their cruising range and explore "off the beaten path". If you are planning to remain in Puget Sound and protected waters planning, semi-displacement or full displacement designs will serve you well. It will be a matter of what design strikes your fancy. If you plan on extending your range to Alaska, Mexico or further forget about a planning hull and look to displacement or semi-displacement.
Dave

as much as I love yachts that pitch on the traits of trawlers has turned my head.I am reminded of the addage a mind is like a parachute it only works when it is open.And now when my ship comes in it might be a trawler!The info in these forums is priceless...namaste

In reviewing many of the "Great Loop" articles, a consistent theme is 'space aboard'.

Trawlers may be romantic, but many would rather make the journey in an aft cabin cruiser as opposed to a Nordic Tug, etc. 'Trawler'.

bump up

Slow but Seaworthy?

To BenSeattle,
re: Trawlers and " Reverse snob appeal "
I think you have difinately hit on something here.
For years, Mercedies denied or played down, any interest in anything, as transient as " Styling ". Marketed as a car for grown ups.
Dignified and a little ponderous.
Gee, sounds like a " trawler ". Maybe...?

Of course, it wasn't true. If anything, styling was very much a concern, with Mercedies.
Lot's of vertical lines. A retro front end.
- Says you can depend on me.
All done with deliberate intent.

This might all seem a little superficial. But I think it merits serious consideration.
As your statement re;
".....seaworthiness...is that true ? "
Along with MacMal's response,
"...wouldn't bet the bank..."
Opens up a very valid line of inquiry. That needs to be considered by potential buyers.

We can draw the very epitome of a " Salty " trawler yacht. Festooned with all manner of cranes and " funnels ".
- Above the water line.
With an apparent absense of Styling...
Beguiling the unwary, into thinking, that they are getting the Real Deal.

Meanwhile; below the water line, critical elements are passed over, in the sales pitch.
How many brokers and/or buyers talk excitedly, about a vessel's Metacentric height - in relation to it's Centre of Gravity ?
Before a couple of million change hands ?

The same percentage of people - no doubt - who inquire as to how much higher, a SUV's C. of G. is compared to the car, they are trading in.
As Brian points out. There is a the parallel popularity, with SUV's and so-called trawlers.
- And they both can suffer the same hidden danger:
- of being too top heavy.
- All to few people realize how much a few inches - in a gain, in height
- combined with, too narrow a track (or beam) can have a serious effect on stability.

Nicely covered up - in the case of a trawler - by all those stabilizers.
Everybodys so fond of.
During sea trials, before purchase, I'd suggest finding out in heavy seas
- how the vessel feels. With out the " flopper stoppers ".

Cheers !

Well, we just had 3 good sized boat shows for yachts in Florida. Did those of you who got to prowl the docks notice any difference in activity between the various types? Trawlers (expedition) vs conventional flybridge vs sport yacht (open) vs sportfishing?

Kelly

sea sick

While Trawlers might be know as a safer platform to travel in, you need to remember that a good deal of the working part of the boat (the helm or helms) are quite a bit above the water line and you WILL get a lot of rocking and seasick people onboard in a rolling sea