Sea cocks: Bronze or composite?

There are things I will never buy when labeled “made in Commie China”: tires, underwater fittings, dog food and treats...

two years ago I replaced all the thruhulls and sea cocks on my boat because they were 48 years old ... all bronze. I don’t think Marelon and other “plastic” fittings would have lasted that long especially when exposed to heat in the ER

Capt Ralph
Just to be accurate , these cocks are not suitable for fuel and oils.

Add people food to that list to me. I try to avoid buying anything made in China. Rarely is their quality very good. Unfortunately some things you have to like Rule float switches.

Took my grandson and some of his friends to dollar store, told them they could all get a toy that was made in America.
Yep, there were none!

Uh, Yes, I know. I thought we were talking about thru hull hardware.
I'm guessing somewhere my S/E swamp accent is causing some translation issue with terminology.

yeah human food too obviously. I m replacing rule float switches with Ultra Switches. Pretty sure they re made in the US and much more reliable!

I hate Rule stuff, but I don't like Ultras, either.
Imho, it's better to leave any electronic components nowhere near bilges.

Not sure if by "I'm replacing" you mean that you already bought the things.
If not, you might consider this alternative.
You'll never find these switches in chandlers, since they are meant for industrial applications.
But you must hit them with a hammer to make them stop working - no matter how harsh the working environment.

Oooh, I like those! Good for water/poop tanks too!

Looks like the original Hatteras level alarm float switch.
Always wondered why they were not use for the pump switch. Maybe no protection from bilge debris?

I wasn't aware that Hatteras ever used them.
I've only seen them on very few boats, and they were all from Italian builders.

Anyhow, yes, the fact that those components weren't specifically designed as bilge switches means that the builder (or anyone interested in retrofitting them) must put a bit of thinking in their location and installation, but their reliability is well worth the effort, imho.

Below is just one example of a possible bilge installation.
The two lower switches are meant to turn on/off the pump at different levels, and the third is an additional alarm, meant to go off if and when the level goes above what the pump can cope with.
But they can be used in any configuration you can think of, since individually they are just extremely simple on/off contacts.

Those look good, like the multiple switch setup. Easy to check and clean.

Indeed. In fact, that photo was taken upon inspection of a 14 years old boat, with all the switches original and still as good as new.

Like that a LOT.

Yes, but if they're not UL rated or ABYC rated for bilge systems, then they probably won't pass classing or some insurance company issues. I like the Ultra switches, but they do hold more bilge water than Rules, AND there's no easy way to test them aside from seeing the green LED lit on them.

I'm not familiar with ABYC requirements, but I doubt that Gavazzi (the producer) bothered to consider them.
Nautical market is meaningless for them, as all their components are meant for industrial applications.
That said, I've seen the above parts also in a vessel built to Lloyd's +100A1 rating, FWIW.

Now, Send pictures of your ship and the hardware replacements. Fill us in on your other projects.
Some of us like to watch...

Guidi is a quality brand. Just hard to find strainer baskets for them here in the U.S., much preferred over Maistrimi with tiny lid bolts, tiny sea strainer basket openings, lid O-rings that swell constantly etc.

I've used Ultra switches and alarms across the board. Old school float switches have always given me fits. Ultras, no issues in many years.

Yes. Bulky particles can cling and impact. In a sense it's the same technology as the Ultra switches, only without the protective housing.